10.1177/1470594X18762256">
 

Title

The self-ownership proviso: A critique

Document Type

Article

Publication Date

2018

Department/School

History and Philosophy

Publication Title

Politics, Philosophy and Economics

Abstract

Recently, Eric Mack, Edward Feser, and Daniel Russell have argued that self-ownership justifies a constraint on the use of property such that an owner’s use of property may not severely negate the ability of others to interact with the world. Mack has labeled this constraint the self-ownership proviso. Adopting this proviso promises right-libertarians a way of avoiding the extreme implications of a no-proviso view, while maintaining a consistent and cohesive position (in contrast, arguably, to Nozick’s understanding and endorsement of Locke’s proviso). Nevertheless, I argue that self-ownership cannot ground the constraint on property use that Mack, Feser, and Russell think that it can.

Link to Published Version

10.1177/1470594X18762256

Share

COinS